By Sean Patrick Kernan
I had to suffer through “The Road” on two separate occasions just to reach the end. Director John Hillcoat's bleak vision of the end of the world is overwrought, ugly and cynical that the first time I had to walk out and get some air. The second time I suffered the whole of “The Road” and then needed a long shower to forget it.
In some unspecified future the world simply begins to consume itself. Whether what happened was environmental, nuclear war or some kind of biblical apocalypse we are not to know. What we do know is that inhabiting this world are The Man (Viggo Mortenson) and The Boy (Codi Smit McPhee).
Together they are making their way to the coast where rumors of a colony of some kind near the ocean give them some kind of hope for the future. More likely, however, is the idea that The Man has invented this idea to give them something to do so that The Boy won't lose hope.
That is pretty well it for plot. The film is more a series of dank, gloomy scenes of sadness and degrading landscape. Things are so awful that even the trees seem to take a sentient stance and decide to simply topple to the ground. The journey along the road for The Man and The Boy is a slow, repetitive journey toward death.
Is “The Road” well realized? Yes, Director John Hillcoat can certainly suck the life out of landscape and star Viggo Mortenson is exceptional at becoming the physical embodiment of decay but don't ask either what the point of it all is. I tried imagining that the point of “The Road” was to have no point at all. That went nowhere and I was left really not caring.
I have not read Cormac McCarthy's much praised novel on which the film is based but I am familiar enough with McCarthy and have read enough about the novel to know that the point in McCarthy is as much about his words as it about anything else. It seems “The Road” the novel was more about the way McCarthy wrote it than about any vision of the apocalypse.
What may have been at the heart of the movie “The Road” is a misunderstanding. Director Hillcoat and screenwriter Joe Penhall assumed that McCarthy was offering judgment on humanity and offering a vision of the end of the world. The reality may be that McCarthy was working in prose and this is where his vision and wordplay took him. However the movie “The Road” came about, whether it is true to McCarthy's vision or not, it is far too depressing, vile and gloomy for me to recommend. Again, I respect the technical work of John Hillcoat, who could suck the life out of even the most scenic locales, and the work of Mr. Mortenson, who immerses himself wonderfully in every role. I just cannot abide such a dark vision without some point. I don't want to live in a world where I cannot find meaning somewhere. There seems to be no meaning, point or purpose anywhere in the ugly cynicism of “The Road.”
BYLINE:
Sean Patrick Kernan is a film critic. Check him out at: http://www.myspace.com/number1ramjamfan.
Friday, December 18, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 comments:
I think the fact that you found the film "depressing, vile, & gloomy" proves how good the film is. It sparked emotion in the viewer and I think that's always the sign of a good film. You were drawn into their pathetic existence.
You failed to find meaning and purpose in the film but I think that illustrating the ultimate pointlessness of human endeavor WAS the point. Who needs another story where everyone lives happily ever after?
the fact that you did not see the point does not mean that there is not one. what kind of hope do you seek in this film? a world is effectively destroyed and our expectation is for redemption. pathetic. movies!! anonymous said it already. read that!
"Having not read the book" is pretty much the reason you didn't get the point. Read it for 20 pages or so and you'll see the father loves his son and will do anything to make sure he survives. Pretty good point, eh?
Even though the world is depressing, vile, and gloomy, there still is hope and love among the impending death of human kind. The love the Man has for his Boy. Also the compassion the Boy shows to several strangers that they pass. Should this not be the point in everyones life the compassion for humankind. Would not the world be a better place if there was more compassion?
please save your one dimensional and shallow critiques for AFTER you have read the book.
pathetic
Post a Comment